May
9, 2006
NIV
Improves Quality of Life For All,
Longevity for Most With ALS
A multi-year study of the effects
of noninvasive ventilation (NIV) for
patients with amyotrophic lateral
sclerosis (ALS) shows that it
improves both survival and quality
of life in people with moderate or
no mouth and throat (bulbar) weakness,
and that it improves quality of life
even in those with severe bulbar weakness.
Stephen Bourke and colleagues at
the University of Newcastle Upon Tyne
(UK) and Newcastle Hospitals Trust,
who published their findings in the
February issue of The Lancet Neurology,
studied 22 people with ALS who were
randomly assigned to standard care
plus NIV, and 19 assigned to standard
care alone. Quality of life was measured
by a battery of questionnaires.
The NIV group survived 48 days (28
percent) longer on average than the
non-NIV group.
When the results from patients with
good bulbar function were segregated
from the total, there was a dramatic
difference, with NIV users surviving
an average of 216 days (more than
seven months) and non-NIV users surviving
an average of 11 days.
Participants with poor bulbar function
showed no survival benefit, and the
investigators speculate that these
patients may have been unable to use
NIV effectively.
The investigators emphasize that
quality of life measurements showed
improvements for all NIV users and
that, while more investigation of
NIV in people with bulbar weakness
should be undertaken, NIV should not
be withheld from them in the meantime.
|